So what do you think of Etsy?
Friday, February 29th, 2008Why I like Etsy?
I love the description in this article about Etsy as an online streetfair. They have so many different ways to browse that this really does apply.
I can browse by color, by material, by location.
(By location!!! How Shop local is that!)
I can even “pounce” seeing undiscovered items or freshly sold items. I love the variety that i’m able to find, and yes custom ordering is a delight.
I’ve got an order placed with JaneBonBon for this dress in this pattern in my size . In MY SIZE!!!! It’s incredibly liberating to have someone custom making a dress for you.
I’m in contact with another seller to see if she will have another one of these skirts available.
If I want it , I can ask for it. While it makes me sad that a number of the silkscreens are only available for small sizes, the ability to custom order other items makes up for it.
And it’s not just clothing. Its soap, and it’s jewelry and art and… Etsy has it all.
Why I wouldn’t sell on Etsy.
If I did have something to sell, I don’t think Etsy would be my venue. First off there is so much there and so much of the same. A search for sock monster gives you 248 results. A search for sock creature gives you another 132. Felt fortune cookies? 38. Sure some of these might be from the same sellers. But on the fortune cookies there were at least 13 sellers selling them. I think you need a unique product and I think perhaps you need to have a small existing customer base to start with. My impression is that it would be hard to stand out amongst such a crowd.
Even soap, which I consider my most sellable product. would put my items among 12,000 others for sale. Yeah, not so much.
And the copycats. The problem isnt just that people see what one person does and goes to copy it, it’s also common inspiration . When you run in a crafty circle its easy to see something and go “Oh Cool I want to do that too” Sock creatures are a trend. Soap Popsicles are a trend. Most anything you see Martha do, thats a trend. Duct tape wallets are a trend. What you see in craft magazine, thats a trend. And on and on and on. I think its hard to say “I created this trend” particularly if you got the idea from somewhere else.
What I find weird on Etsy.
Selling food. I just can’t imagine buying Lemon bars, Brownies , Cookies, Cake, or Pie .
This is all my own bias but I can’t imagine paying $15 for 6 brownies. (Sure they are huge, but really buying brownies online?)
Jams and Jellies sure look tasty, but I guess I’d feel better if I knew these were made in a clean kitchen (or if I knew the person making them)
What I’m dying to buy
A bag from Janine King
A leather journal from Artisian Graham
An engraved moleskin
A stationary set
Yarn from Midnight and LuLu
Soap from Mad City Sue
Tags and more from Elle’s Studio
Bath Scrubs from A Garden Bath








