Four copies of the same cookbook
Sunday, October 29th, 2006I’ve tried to keep my collecting to a minimum. I dont gravitate to the typical dust collectors. I don’t like Knick Knacks that have to be dusted and the only real things I keep around for "cuteness" factors are stuffed animals. I have a handful of them and plans to reduce their number to the ones that actually matter.
I’m much more susceptible to collecting printed matter, particulary magazines and cookbooks. While I’ve gotten better about weeding through my cookbooks I’m not great at it, and as you can see I’ve collected four of the exact same cookbook.
From left to right we have my 1936 edition, my new 1962 edition, my 1975 edition and my 1993 edition. I dont have the new 2006 edition yet. (Maybe for Christmas I’ll get it) I’m also hoping for a 1940′s edition with the war rationing information.
So why multiple copies of a cookbook?
First, this isnt just any cookbook. This is the Joy of Cooking. This is the book many people consider the cooking bible. Copies are given as wedding presents, when you go off to college, and at least one person is trying to cook all of it. (and I too have considered that task )When I need a basic basic recipe its the first one I grab for off of my shelf. Sometimes I grab the 1975 version, more often it’s the 1993 version.
It’s this cookbook that has given me
- Pancakes better then our favorite restaurant
- A good back up hollandaise
- A great biscuit recipe
- A tasty cobbler recipe
- A decent Veggie Soup
- A fantastic greek lemon rice soup
- A good pasta recipe
- a tasty pasta sauce
- my favorite "chocolate pudding" recipe (pots du creme are divine)
So why multiple copies?
Because the 1970′s version includes a picture of how to skin a squirrel. Because the 1960′s edition includes a recipe for a diet dressing "that doesnt taste good, but is good if you are reducing" The 1936 edition assures you that things will be ok, if you just read the notes before you start. Because all of them use the work Cockaigne, which seems to mean "fancied" and then there are the menus.
The menus are a sight to behold. With lists of what to make for a light tea, a hearty brunch or a special holiday.
For example, a supper menu in 1936 was
- Spinach Ring, with creamed sweetbreads
- Rice Muffins
- Jam
- A Beverage
A supper menu in 1962
- Cheese , Bread and Egg Dish
- Green Salad with Bacon
- Chives and catsup dressing
- Fresh Peaches
- Oatmeal Chocolate chip cookies
- A beverage
A supper in 1975
- Liver Lyonnaise
- Shoestring Potatoes
- Sweet Sour Beans
- Blueberries and cream (and yes there is recipe for this)
A supper in 1993
- Creamed mushrooms with dried porcini over toast
- Satueed pork tenderloin medalions
- Roasted potatoes, beets and onions vinagrette
- Field Salad with fresh herbs
- Linzertorte
While I dont think I’ll ever cook my way through the Joy of Cooking I do think I might try sampling recipes of the same name from different editions to see if there are any differences,
While I dnt think I’ll ever cook my way through it I do think I might try some comparison recipes. Picking a recipe in one version and seeing if I can cook throuhg all the different



